Criticisms of Recognition Despite its influence and popularity, there are a number of concerns regarding the concept of recognition as a foundational element in a theory of justice.
IELTS essay sample for topic – Respecting the elderly.
Respect is lost when anyone becomes a dependent on others for their physical and financial survival.
Older people generally become less self reliant and vulnerable as they age, in many western countries they are left to fend for themselves in old age homes or communities for seniors.
Read more be recognised negatively, or misrecognised, is to be thwarted in our desire for authenticity and self-esteem. Taylor defends a politics of difference, arguing that the concept of equal dignity often (if not always) derives its idea of what rights and entitlement are worth having from the perspective of the hegemonic culture, thus enforcing minority groups to conform to the expectations.
In this instance, all individuals are to be treated as universally the same through recognition of their common citizenship or humanity.
Important discussions of groups as entities include Tuomela (2007 Jones (2009) and List and Pettit (2011).
He describes our respective perspectives on the world as slipping into one another and thus being brought together: In reality, the other is not shut up inside my perspective of the world, because this perspective itself has no definite limits, because it slips spontaneously into. Hegel introduces the idea of a struggle for recognition, describing an encounter between two self-consciousnesses which both seek to affirm the certainty of their being for themselves (Hegel, 1807: 232ff.).
In Asian cultures, they live with their families often with children and grand children.
There are many other reasons why seniors are not always shown respect.