A critic is, primarily, an attentive and deeply interested reader.Literary criticism estimates the main contemporary trends of the literary development; it interprets the works of art from the perspective of the present. An ideal article critique example is an attempt to shed light on the literary product so that the potential readers can decide for themselves if this work is worth reading or not.Tags: Discovery EssayResearch Paper Rubric ElementaryPlato Alry Of The Cave EssayCriteria For Writing A Reflective EssayCreative Ways To Write A Love LetterAnalysis Essay Everyday Use Alice WalkerFederal Resume Writing Service ReviewsSales Programs Business Plan
However the author's disagreement with Boote and Baile on the centrality of relevance reflects a division within the educational research community over the proper form and goal of literature review that are part of dissertations and dissertation proposals.
According to the author, this division is between those who hold a traditional view that a thorough literature review for a dissertation's research area should be done and those who want a selective review of the literature review relating directly to the proposed study.
After all, writers often do not understand all the aspects of their writing and the critic’s task is to dispel the shadow of misunderstanding around writers' works.
In the modern world, a critic and his knowledge about how to critique an article play an important role in the development of the reading market and formation of a reader's perception.
The author agrees with Boote and baile's claims as being in consistence with his experience in teaching and advising the doctoral students and according to the authors view the authors' conception of a proper dissertation literature reviews undercuts the values of their insights because they emphasize on thoroughness and comprehensiveness which confounds literature review articles for publications with dissertation literature reviews and therefore the authors( boote and Baile) misses the relevance of centrality.
Hence the author argues that the neglect of relevance leads them (other authors) to misrepresent the essential characteristics of a good dissertation literature review and to propose inappropriate standards for evaluating such reviews.
There is need to educate doctoral candidates on the goal of the dissertation writing which is to read and use published research as opposed to literature review.
Other than research preparation, relevance is an important component for the doctoral candidates because they need to understand and use research findings from various topic areas that are widely covered.
Author Ante began with an example, the satellite-radio war, to show how ethnography worked in business.
In satellite-radio war, Sirius Satellite Ratio made a team of social scientists, designers, and ethnographers.